Sign Up Sign In

How do I prevent clumps when using cornstarch to thicken a soup?


I've made cold cherry soup a few times from a recipe that calls for thickening it with a little cornstarch, but I always end up with some small clumps of what I presume are the starch in the finished soup. I don't cook with cornstarch much, so I don't know where in the process I'm going wrong.

The recipe calls for cooking the cherries in water with spices for a while and then combining cornstarch (2 tablespoons, in this recipe) with a like amount of the hot soup mix, stirring rapidly to combine, and then stirring that back into the pot of soup. (While trying to diagnose my problem I've come across other recipes that call for combining the cornstarch with cold water. That's not what I did. I haven't tried that.) When I combined the liquid with the cornstarch I couldn't get all the lumps out, so I added some more soup from the pot until I got something that seemed smooth. I then stirred that back into the pot and, again, everything seemed smooth, though it's easier for clumps to hide among cherries than in a bowl of liquid. I then simmered that for a while longer before cooling it, letting it sit out until it was cool enough to safely put in the fridge.

Where did I go wrong with the cornstarch? What do I need to change the next time I make this? This has happened to me a few times, but I only pit that many fresh cherries about once a year, so I always manage to forget by the next time I'm doing this. This time I remembered to ask the question. :-)

I have considered just leaving it out, preferring a thinner soup to lumps, but learning how to properly use cornstarch will probably help me with other cooking in the future, too.

Why should this post be closed?

1 comment

Instead of using cornstarch as thickening agent, you could also use roux, cream or tomate paste (if the soup is based on tomatoes) - these come with the advantage that they already are liquids so they can't form clumps. Zerotime 20 days ago

1 answer


Corn starch acts like a gelatin when heated, sticking to other food and itself. As your reading seems to suggest, the key is to use cold water to form the starchy paste, making sure it is fully mixed and lump-free before adding to the hot soup. It's normal for all the starch to want to settle to the bottom, just make sure it's well distributed before adding to your dish.


Sign up to answer this question »

This site is part of the Codidact network. We have other sites too — take a look!

You can also join us in chat!

Want to advertise this site? Use our templates!